I just spent some time working on adding BoostBox to stablekraft.app and I'm not 100% if the recipients even see the URL since I don't really see it in my testing.

Claude side it depends on the payment server weather or not it's passed a long which I think is correct.

I get this info in Alby from Fountain, Castamatic and PodcastGuru so I knownn be it works but I just don't know how well.

BoostBox Boost 01KJ3BG2YPE398H0RWT6V43P1S

(boostbox.cloud)

Still feels like we're beholden to the wallets doing it this way which is the point Alecks Gates was making by moving this out of the payment flow and into the feed.

All of this payment metadata stuff has always been broken and that's why Helipad on a Node is still king for all of this.

What's the fix? idk but this stuff makes my head hurt.

"Can't see your BoostBox URL? Get a better wallet." Coming soon.

I just spent some time working on adding BoostBox to stablekraft.app and I'm not 100% if the recipients even see the URL since I don't really see it in my testing.

Claude side it depends on the payment server weather or not it's passed a long which I think is correct.

I get this info in Alby from Fountain, Castamatic and PodcastGuru so I knownn be it works but I just don't know how well.

BoostBox Boost 01KJ3BG2YPE398H0RWT6V43P1S

(boostbox.cloud)

@ChadF not sure I understand what's happening. You mean your payments don’t carry the url in the comments?

@francosolerio

yeah this is from Castamatic in my AlbyHub but I cant always get this info to send with my app.

Some work and some dont. Strike and Zeus for example are fine so i think its just based on the wallet the payment is being sent to.

@ChadF probably not all wallets support sending comments

@francosolerio

I think thats it since it does work. I've had this issue before testing other stuff.

@ChadF @francosolerio is the problem for you specifically when you're using the Alby web browser extension? If yes, have you asked Alby about it?

It'd be great if we had a list of what LN wallets support sending metadata with lnaddress transactions.

@mitch @francosolerio

I think it depends on the receivers wallet but I'm not 100% sure on that and honestly need to read up on all of this.

I've only tested the Alby extension with BoostBox in my app so far but I think I have it working so I can try others.

Strike and Primal so far seem to handle receiving these well so far. Primal is kind of nice because it shows up as a click able link in the wallet.

@francosolerio @ChadF hmm I suppose it would make sense if the ability to receive a memo with an lnaddress is configured on the recipients LN node itself? And since Alby lets people connect their own node, there would be no guarantee that an “Alby wallet” accepts a memo with an LN-Invoice? Are you bringing your own node by chance?

@merryoscar could you help shed some light on the lnaddress memo behavior? Is it controlled by the LN node? I’m probably getting some of my terminology wrong…

@francosolerio @ChadF hmm I suppose it would make sense if the ability to receive a memo with an lnaddress is configured on the recipients LN node itself? And since Alby lets people connect their own node, there would be no guarantee that an “Alby wallet” accepts a memo with an LN-Invoice? Are you bringing your own node by chance?

@merryoscar could you help shed some light on the lnaddress memo behavior? Is it controlled by the LN node? I’m probably getting some of my terminology wrong…

@mitch @francosolerio @ChadF

The ability to receive a comment alongside a payment to a Lightning Address is configured by the Lightning Address server - it's defined here - https://github.com/lnurl/luds/blob/luds/12.md

To include the comment you pass it as a query string parameter in the pay request like ?comment={rss::payment...}

Most Lightning Address providers support this feature - Fountain, Strike, Primal, Alby etc

@ChadF what receiving wallet did you test with that wasn't accepting the comment param?

@merryoscar @mitch @francosolerio

Oscar

Fountain and Alby but with Alby I was sending to myself so that might be why that's having issues but it's still sending the payment so that strange.

Here's my Fountain walllet from the test.

Reference - OHGini2GJ9DP0y2wq9MV

This is using episode 1 of my test feed. https://podcastindex.org/podcast/7405721

@mitch @francosolerio @ChadF

The ability to receive a comment alongside a payment to a Lightning Address is configured by the Lightning Address server - it's defined here - https://github.com/lnurl/luds/blob/luds/12.md

To include the comment you pass it as a query string parameter in the pay request like ?comment={rss::payment...}

Most Lightning Address providers support this feature - Fountain, Strike, Primal, Alby etc

@ChadF what receiving wallet did you test with that wasn't accepting the comment param?

@merryoscar @ChadF @francosolerio that clears it up a lot. Thanks!

@ChadF @mitch @francosolerio

I've just deployed a change that should fix the issue you're seeing - as long as you include the feed_guid in the rss::payment metadata - the fountain wallet should show the matching episode

Would you mind sending another test?

@merryoscar @mitch @francosolerio

Still nothing DMwEzrS3U3mTHoKPnrNl

These also don't show up when sending from Castamatic.

Here's the ref from Castamatic.

rb4YsBiPpBb62sY1BJBu

@ChadF @mitch @francosolerio

It's working with your streaming payments from castamatic:

{
"action": "STREAM",
"split": 78,
"app_name": "Castamatic",
"app_version": "12.0.4",
"sender_name": "ChadF",
"recipient_name": "longy",
"recipient_address": "longy@fountain.fm",
"value_msat": 35000,
"value_msat_total": 52000,
},

Can you try another test boost to your fountain wallet and I'll report back with the logs?

@merryoscar @mitch @francosolerio

Boosted my test episode from Castamatic since that's working for streams.

ZuJNUkKNZH0Zvv8BiCcP

I also just Boosted that episode I was listening to.